Welcome to Sam's Pizza
Sam's Pizza, located in Oglesby, IL, is a culinary gem renowned for its authentic homemade pizza. Owned by the charismatic Sam, this one-man operation excels in crafting fresh dough and rich sauces, reminiscent of traditional Italian pizzerias. Guests rave about the warm, familial atmosphere and the incredible value for money. With a menu that boasts rich, flavorful cheese pizza and unique toppings, visitors often find themselves coming back for more. Whether you're unwinding after a hike at Starved Rock or just craving quality pizza, Sam’s friendly service and hearty portions make it a must-visit destination.
-
115 S Columbia Ave, Oglesby, IL 61348, United States115 S Columbia Ave, Oglesby, IL 61348, United States Hotline: +1 815-883-9413
Welcome to Sam's Pizza, a charming gem nestled in the heart of Oglesby, Illinois. Located at 115 S Columbia Ave, this delightful establishment is not just a pizza shop, but a culinary experience that feels like family. With just a phone call away at +1 815-883-9413, you’re always welcomed back, even if it involves navigating a busy moment in Sam’s bustling kitchen.
What sets Sam’s Pizza apart is the genuine connection that owner Sam cultivates with his customers. Described as funny and super friendly, he treats every visitor like a cherished family member. Sam takes pride in his craft, making his own pizza dough and sauce from scratch, truly embracing the spirit of authentic Italian cuisine. Customers rave about the rich, flavorful pizzas that have become legendary, particularly the cheese pizza, which one visitor claimed was the most decadent they've ever tasted.
Many have made special trips just to experience the magic that is Sam’s Pizza, often stopping by after a day of exploration at nearby attractions like Starved Rock State Park. It’s apparent from numerous reviews that this isn't just about pizza—it's about creating a unique, memorable experience. A loyal patron once remarked, "The value is insane," highlighting that for the quality and taste you get, the prices feel like a steal. Diners often find themselves returning for more, tempted by the delicious offerings and Sam's infectious humor.
Despite occasional communication quirks, visitors leave feeling enchanted, not just by the food, but by the laughter and warmth that fills the air. The atmosphere is relaxed and intimate; Sam’s personal touch can make even the busiest nights feel special. It’s difficult to walk away without a smile or a full stomach, as patrons frequently find themselves enjoying more slices than they intended.
In summary, Sam's Pizza is more than just a meal; it’s an experience to be savored. Whether you’re a local or a traveler exploring the area, stepping into Sam's world means enjoying delicious pizza crafted with love and laughter. Don’t miss this extraordinary pizzeria on your journey; it’s a must-visit, where every slice tells a story and every visit feels like coming home.
Sam, the owner, is super friendly and funny. He interacts with his customers like they are family. He makes his own pizza dough as if he was in Italy. The value is insane. He should be charging more. Great taste and value! I wish I could go back.
Came from Chicago to Starved Rock and tried Sam’s Pizza. We paid 1,500(discounted from 9,532) for the most rich and flavorful Cheese Pizza I’ve ever had. Please if you come here respect this man’s craft. He is just one man and he makes the dough and sauce himself. Sam’s a bit hard to understand but he’s hilarious and friendly. Treat Sam as if you were in his home, and enjoy a delicious pizza.
This is one of those town favorites, great pizza, Sam's hard working one man show. And everyone keeps coming back for a reason. If they phone isn't going through, just order in person Sam sometimes gets too busy to attend calls.
Best homemade pizza. We stopped by after hiking at Starved rock state park and reading all the positive reviews we decided to try this place. The joint takes you back to time, Sam is an amazing person to interact with and funny. He is really hardworking and super fast as well, we got our pizza within 20 mins. For 10 I was expecting the pizza to be average, but I was so wrong. I ended up eating more slices than I usually do. I would go back again. This is a must visit when you are in Oglesby.
I'm not too sure how to describe what I just witnessed.... The pizza was good. The prices were crazy good. I didn't want sausage but I got it anyway and he insisted. It was good. I'm glad I didn't walk out when I walked in. Sam is hilarious. I'm not sure if he's deaf or not. I'm not sure if he snuck out of the nursing home and he's got the real Sam in the back tied up? But I'm glad we found this place. We were traveling and hungry! "Happy Easter"!?! And "moor powwa"... I gave him 20 for a 10 pizza because... I think I was hypnotized? I'm not sure. You'll have to see for yourself... It was a 3 star pizza but.... I'm so confused.
Pizza was amazing. Sam is very funny. It was definitely worth the wait. Suggest to Go inside and order he’s getting a little old and might need reminded. Definitely would come back. Cheap pizza!
Stopping by here is like taking a journey to the past. Sam will chat up a storm with you, with a healthy interjection of witty remarks, while he makes your pizza. You get real ingredients baked in an oven right in front of you, served in a paper bag. It's great to still have places like this around.
This pizza place is a hidden gem! The prices are unbeatable, and the atmosphere has that cozy, small-town charm. The pizza is delicious, with fresh ingredients and generous portions. Highly recommend!